Monday, January 24, 2011

Class #1: Introduction to Course 2011

We presented statistics on Women in Indiana and the health needs of our state. Were you surprised that we are in the bottom half of the country with regard to health indicators? Many of the issues we face are the direct results of lifestyle. How long will it take to turn lives around and begin people on paths to a healthier tomorrow? Should we start with people your age and leave the over 40 crowd to what they have already become accustomed to or should we strive to get everyone moving toward a Healthy Indiana.


Have you ever tried a major lifestyle change? Think of something you really enjoy - like a Diet coke. Could you go a day without it or a week? What would make you stay the course or do you fall back into old habits?

Have you looked at the goals of Healthy People 2020?  link to website  Healthy People 2020

What are your thoughts?

13 comments:

  1. Before clusters (a long long time ago, it seems), I used to drink caffeinated beverages on a daily basis and usually had multiple throughout the day. However I discovered that when clusters came around P1 year and I needed a little boost to keep me studying, I would no longer get anything from a mountain dew or two. So I cut myself off from all caffeine containing drinks for the express purpose of being able to use them on an as needed basis during clusters.
    As expected, I got several bad headaches from the withdrawal, and had to cave to half a can of coke for the first week or two to help wean myself off. Fortunately however, I am now able to drink a mountain dew here and there during clusters and actually get a boost to help me through studying.
    I have a feeling that once clusters are over with, I may fall back into drinking caffeinated drinks more frequently once again.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Indiana’s ranking in regard to health indicators was a bit surprising, and honestly quite concerning, to me. I had never realized how dire the situation is. I was interested to see what states ranked in the top positions, and if I am recalling correctly, found Vermont, Massachusetts, and Hawaii in the top three positions, respectively. I think another fascinating discussion would be to determine what these states are doing, policy-wise and mandate-wise, that allow them the distinction to be ranked so high. Perhaps even comparing their lifestyles and mentalities about diet, exercise, overall well-being, etc. might be fruitful. Maybe Indiana may be afforded an opportunity to think about changes and progress on a positive slope to a better report card. VT, MA, and HI are by no means the barometers by which Indiana should measure its success, as I am positive those respective states have other struggles in health care as well, but perhaps studying the trends and tendencies of “healthier” states might be useful.
    I do not think it is too late to reverse our ranking and attempt to inspire people to begin on a healthier path. I am not certain of how long it will take to do so because old habits die hard – in our society, it seems ingrained in people partake of pleasurable and potentially unhealthy things – huge portions of fast food, lounging on the couch watching reality TV, and so forth. I think everyone can definitely benefit from an overhaul of an unhealthy lifestyle and implementation of a healthy lifestyle – even those who are over 40. Teaching my generation the importance of such a life provides the message, to those even younger, of the benefits of healthy living; teaching the generation over 40 the benefits of healthy living provides the message that it is never too late to do something.
    With my wedding coming up next year, a concern of mine has been looking (and feeling) great on my wedding day in that wedding dress. So a major lifestyle change has been portion control, calorie counting, and attempting an exercise routine at least four times a week. I am a comfort eater and love big portions, so I have had to learn to tame that habit. I think what has helped me stay the course has been keeping the endpoint in mind all the time – feeling great and being healthier not just on my wedding day, but for the rest of my life.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Lifestyle is obviously a huge contributor to obesity, but I think it is important to provide education to people of all ages about the importance of adopting a healthy lifestyle. No matter what age a person is, eating a healthy diet and being active are beneficial.
    It's interesting that many of the states with the worst obesity rankings (Mississippi, Alabama, Arkansas, etc.) are also in the bottom ranks concerning household income while states with lower obesity rates tend to have higher household incomes. It is a lot cheaper to buy unhealthy, processed food with more calories than it is to buy fresh fruits and vegetables and lean protein. Also, people with higher incomes may be more likely to have a gym membership or be able to afford exercise equipment, personal trainers, and other things that help motivate them toward a healthy lifestyle.
    Every year during Lent I give up something I really enjoy, but I always go back to my old habits once Lent is over. The biggest lifestyle change I made was to begin exercising consistently and watching my diet during my junior year of high school. Now between school and work I am not as consistent as I was when I had more time. I definitely felt more self confident and better overall when I was more dedicated to a healthy diet and exercise, so I have been trying to get back into the habit of both.

    ReplyDelete
  4. If you look at the people who come into your pharmacy or hospital, the statistics make sense. The hospital beds keep having to get bigger!

    In regards to whether we try to influence changes in younger or older generations, I think that parents have a huge impact in shaping their children's attitudes towards diet and exercise and health. If the focus is on people our age getting healthy and then influencing their future children to be healthy, real change could be seen. It may be harder to sway the over 40 crowd on lifelong habits, but they shouldn't be ignored either. Ideally, everyone should strive towards a Healthy Indiana with different approaches towards the older and younger generations since their needs and influences on other vary.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I was not that surprised to see that Indiana ranked so low with regard to health indicators. Driving is a way of life these days, nobody walks anywhere which combined with advancements in technology that make it more appealing to stay at home watching TV or searching for things on the internet greatly diminish the amount of physical activity the typical American does. Also, all you have to do is spend some time in Broadripple to see the major prevalence of smoking in the state of Indiana. Any bar you enter you are immediately hit in the face with the smell of smoke. I think in order to change the health status of Indiana we need to change how people live their lives and find a way to convey to the general public how their habits affect their health. I think the best way to do that is focus on simple changes people can make to improve their overall health and help to educate them on what changes they can make that will make them healthier later in life. Unfortunately, due to budget cuts many schools have been forced to cut sports programs and physical fitness classes. If we do not instill in our children at a young age healthy eating habits and the importance of daily physical activity (and most importantly the fact that physical activity can be fun) then there is no hope for improving the overall health of the nation as a whole.

    Over the past couple of years I have gotten into a habit where I will drink at least one or two Mountain Dews a day leading up to clusters but then right after clusters end I force myself to stop drinking any caffeine cold turkey because I really don’t like how addicted I get to that caffeine and the thought of having a soda every day just based on empty calories. Every time that I try to stop drinking caffeine the first week is really hard. During that first week I have to deal with major caffeine withdrawal headaches and afternoon drowsiness and sometimes just wonder why I put myself through the pain of stopping caffeine when I know in a few short weeks the whole cycle will begin again as I start preparing for the next set of clusters. But once I get past that first hard week it feels really good not to be reliant on a can of soda or two daily to be able to function and it makes it so much better when I start drinking Mountain Dew again and can really appreciate it instead of it being something I need to avoid a major headache in the morning.

    ReplyDelete
  6. It was not surprising to found out that Indiana was near the bottom regarding healthy lifestyle. Many people are watching television to relax after long days of work instead of going to the gym. Most jobs today entail employees to sit at their desk and only get up to go eat lunch or go to the bathroom. There is not much time left to go work out. I hope that it will not take too long for people to become healthier tomorrow; however, I do not believe this will happen until they personally see someone get an illness from being unhealthy. Everyone should strive to a Healthy Indiana.

    Each year I try a major lifestyle change during Lent, trying something new each year. I have attempted to give up eating various types of candy. In the beginning, it does not seem to be too difficult. By about day 10, there are endless temptations to just grab that piece of gum or chocolate bar. I would try to substitute the candy cravings with something else but nothing would work. My bad habits always seem to overcome and win. I was not able to fully succeed. Maybe I will have more luck this year.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I'm not surprised that Indiana is in the bottom half of the country with regard to health indicators and I agree, it seems like most of the issues could be solved by lifestyle changes.

    Since the beginning of our education at Butler we have been taught all about various illnesses and disease states. And for a lot of the diseases we have found that obesity and smoking are risk factors. Because of our education we are given the tools to learn and expand our knowledge. The general public is told that "obesity leads to heart disease", or "obesity leads to diabetes"…but does the general public really know what that means? Do they really know how serious these conditions are? We know, because we have learned in depth about the risks, pathophysiology, consequences, etc.

    Growing up in household with an overweight parent, I didn’t fully understand the significance obesity, I just thought it was normal. As a child I just thought my mom was bigger than other mom's, but who cares? Then, as I got older, I saw being overweight as more of an image issue. I would work out for hours, just to make sure I didn't move up a pant size. I didn't care why I should be a healthy weight, I only cared about not looking fat. It wasn't until I came to Butler and started having lectures about all of these diseases that I really truly understood why being obese is so unhealthy.

    Since starting college, I have tried and tried and tried to pass along this information to my mom. But no matter how hard I try, it just doesn't seem to sink in. I have tried rationally explaining it to her, I have tried being angry and yelling at her about her various bad habits, I have tried scaring her into being more healthy, and I have even tried pulling the guilt card because I'm scared for her future (and my future without her). Obviously these tactics are not working, just like they are not working on the national level.

    Maybe through better national education, the general public can start to learn more of WHY they shouldn’t be obese. Maybe through better education programs and techniques, the general public would be able to put the pieces of the puzzle together and realize that poor lifestyle habits lead to diseases that will affect them for the rest of their lives. How can we, as pharmacists, take our education, and portray it to our patients in a way that will make them feel motivated enough to change their bad habits for good?

    ReplyDelete
  8. I am truly not surprised that Indiana is ranked so poorly in regard to health indicators. LAH is totally right with the "hospital beds keep having to get bigger" comment. My hospital just recently had to upgrade to a larger size bed in each room to accommodate the patients. Even the seats in the waiting areas throughout the hospital seem to be getting bigger.

    Its never too late to make a change, but implementing lifestyle changes that actually last a lifetime is extremely hard to do (I fail miserably every time I try to give up Diet Dr. Pepper or Coke Zero). It takes commitment and discipline. Changes are being made in schools to promote healthier eating habits by removing junk food options from lunch menus and taking away vending machines. But, these types of changes don't solve the fundamental problem. Healthy behaviors are learned, and people need to be able to make healthy choices when they are out in the "real world."

    I am interested to see how the fad of weight loss reality TV shows impacts the nation. It seems like almost every network has some type of weight loss show from the Biggest Loser to shows on A&E and MTV.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I was a little surprised that Indiana is ranked so low... I was particularly surprised by the very high rate of women smokers. I knew that we would probably be in the top half of smokers, but I was not expecting to be ahead of the states that grow tobacco and have very cheap cigarettes.

    I think that better health should be a goal for everyone, but I think it's most important to target younger people. Children who are obese are more likely to become obese adults, and it is really hard to reverse decades of poor health choices, overeating, etc. If interventions can be done on children, maybe they will have a better chance to become healthy adults - and in turn, raise their children to have healthy lifestyles.

    I know that I personally have a very hard time making good health choices. I always start off every semester working out several times a week, eating less junk food, eating more fruits and veggies... and then after about the first cluster hits, I start feeling like I don't have time to work out, I eat a lot of fast food, and I stop doing any food preparation that's more complicated than warming up a tv dinner. I also find the cost of healthy foods to be really discouraging - for $2 I can get a double cheeseburger and fries from McDonalds, or I can get a single bell pepper from the grocery store. As Jamie mentions above, it's no wonder that there's a link between poverty and obesity.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Sadly, I was not surprised that Indiana ranked so low in health standings and has a high rate of obesity. How Americans spend their leisure time has dramatically changed over the past 25 years which I believe has had a direct impact on the obesity epidemic in the United States. Instead of children running around outside with their friends, they are sitting in front of a TV or computer for hours at end. There has been not only a decrease in physical exercise but an increase in eating as "entertainment." I am guilty of using food as a tool to entertain my friends. I can't remember the last time I got together with friends to take a walk or play a game of tennis rather than grabbing a meal at a restaurant. Until Americans begin to use exercise as a source of entertainment instead of food, I do not believe anything will change.

    Having recently begun grocery shopping for two on a strict budget, I have firsthand experienced the difficulty of choosing healthy options. Not only is frozen or canned food more affordable but it seems to be more practical as well. I am finding it tough to use all of the fresh food I buy before it goes bad. (Just last week, I had to throw out an entire head of lettuce.)

    Being healthy is not easy in this society. Everyone has to make a conscious effort to make their health a priority. And in the current times, it is a constant battle to make these smart choices.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Thanks to all who took the time to comment. Your comments show thought and consideration. You can (I think) set up the blog so you get an email notice every time someone adds a comment which makes it easier to keep up with discusison.

    Now go on the Second thought area - this time on eating disorders. Is it about control or is it an all or nothing response. "If I cannot establish a balance between food needs and desires - I just won't eat". Do you have any experiences from our campus you can share anonymously and whether you noticed or were able to do anything about the situation? 'Food and Feelings' seem extremely interwoven in our lives plus the addition of alcohol and smoking for some. How does that add to the complexity?

    ReplyDelete
  12. I can't speak from personal experience or even knowing someone with an eating disorder but I would guess it is a control issue. It seems like all of the girls in the movie had an unfortunate circumstance (such as a parents divorce or the Mom overseas in the military) that triggered the eating disorder. These circumstances were out of their control and I feel like the girls were just looking for something they could control, such as their weight. Every girl has insecurities in our society so I feel like it wouldn't take very much for a girl to slip into an eating disorder. I agree that food and feelings are extremely interwoven. I mean, who doesn't feel better after eating a huge bowl of ice cream? It seems that a lot of people use food, alcohol, or smoking as a sort of therapy. It makes them forget about the bad things going on in life and experience something pleasurable. However, using these things as therapy is a big problem. It could be causing the dependence on these things every time you have a bad day or every time something goes wrong which could then lead to the path of addiction. Instead of going down that path, there are definitely healthier options of dealing with problems such as talking to a friend or going to work out.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I wanted to comment on the above topic because of interesting observations that begin in Walmart. I have traveled a lot mainly in Hispanic countries (Spain, Mexico, and Colombia). Everytime I am there and then come back to the U.S. and go to Walmart, I am overwhelmed by how big Indiana's people are. Also, in Mexico, the majority of people are average but then the Hispanics from Mexico that live here are becoming more and more overweight. It is just interesting to see such a starck contrast in cultures.

    As for giving up something: throughout my life I have tried and sometimes successfully changed my eating habits (I don't drink pop or beef or pork) but it would be incredibly hard to suddenly change all your eating habits like if you were diagnosed with diabetes and sugar is out (i love my desserts). That leads me to food and feelings. I used to be worse at this. In high school, I had a year were I was overwhelmed and somewhat depressed (with school, boyfriend, and home) and I found myself continually eating because it was the only comfort. I gained weight and lost self-esteem which lead me to eating more. It wasn't until college that I learned to better control my eating habits and exercise/healthy living. It still feels great to have dark chocolate when I am stressed during clusters. Food is a huge part of feelings because when you are happy or celebrate you eat and when you are sad and depressed you usually eat too. I think it would be interesting to find out what causes people to eat more or less, since everyone is different.

    ReplyDelete