Tuesday, February 8, 2011

Class #3: America the Beautiful and Media Images

CLASS #3 – Body Image –and – “America the Beautiful”


In class we watched the movie "America the Beautiful" where it spotlighted a 12 year old girl who becomes a model for fashions because she is >6 foot tall and can walk well in heels. They also dealt with the topic of plastic surgery for perfection, media messages, and self-esteem. What is the need of the US for physical perfection and what is the fall-out if you don't think you fit the desires of others? Where does happiness come from? Where does self-esteem come from? If you were providing counsel to your 6th grade or 7th grade younger sisters or cousins - what words of wisdom would you share?

As food for thought - look at some of the comments for the YouTube video. Any reactions?? Also a short video on PhotoShop is posted.

14 comments:

  1. I found it interesting that the video on Photoshop stated that women and girls don't know how many pictures are photoshopped, and to what extent. In my opinion, that doesn't even necessarily matter - even if we know those pictures aren't real, we're still getting the message that it's desirable to look as close to those images as possible. The women aren't being photoshopped just to take away a flyaway hair or something - they have their bodies reshaped to be as thin as possible, which is still giving us all the message that it's important and desirable to be thin and beautiful.

    I think it's hard to know what message to even give young girls - is it better to tell them that everyone is beautiful? To tell them there are many different standards of beauty and they don't have to conform to the mainstream standard? That looks don't matter anyway? No matter how you phrase it, it's difficult to get any of those messages across. I think the best thing is to simply try to be a good role model - as someone stated in class, it's so damaging for young children to hear their mothers call themselves fat or ugly. I have a friend whose New Years resolution was not to talk negatively about her body, particularly around her 4 year old daughter - I think that's really commendable.

    ReplyDelete
  2. The “America the Beautiful” video was very interesting. One of the first things that stands out in my mind were some of the outrageous comments made by some of the guys in the video regarding their views on women. The men all seemed to agree that they want beautiful, thin, physically perfect women, but none of them really knew why. Another topic the movie touched on was photo shopping. I believe most people realize photos are touched up, but that doesn’t mean we don’t still feel inferior when looking at them because the models in those photos are promoted as being what everyone should strive for. In the YouTube videos the host and dietician suggested putting warnings on photos that are photo-shopped might be more realistic than making it illegal. While I don’t think photo-shopping will ever be made illegal, there must be some solution for limiting the amount of touching up allowed or making the public aware of exactly what goes into making models look the way they do. I find it refreshing when actresses on magazine covers ask for their photo to be left to look more like their body in reality and less touched up. For example, Jamie Lee Curtis posed for a picture in spandex in which she was not touched up at all to show what she really looks like.
    Promoting self esteem to young girls is important, but complicated. I feel like pre-teen and teenage girls are unsure of how they feel about themselves, so they look to others for approval maybe more so than older women who are more comfortable in their own skin. As an older sister and cousin, I try to be a good role model. One of my cousins is in 7th grade, and definitely struggles with self-esteem issues, so I try to boost her confidence whenever I can. Even though I still struggle with my self-esteem and self-image sometimes, I find it comforting and encouraging hearing women in their 30s, 40s, etc. saying that they have become more comfortable in their own skin with age and maturity.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Between body image, in terms of the desire to be thin, and the pressure to be beautiful, it is nearly impossible for young girls growing up in our society to not be affected by the images of "perfection" forced on them daily. Girls are starting to wear make-up earlier and dressing more provocatively sooner. They want to grow up so quickly!

    When it comes to insecurity issues about beauty, I believe the most important thing any young girl needs in her life is a role model, whether it be a mother, older sister, etc., that teaches her what is really important in life. How this role model responds to issues of beauty and self-worth on a daily basis really affects how young girls think about the concept of beauty and confidence. Feeling beautiful on the inside is essential to feeling beautiful on the outside. You have to love who you are, imperfections and all, before you'll be able to accept love from someone else. You could be the most gorgeous women in a room, but if you are not happy with yourself, the looks and compliments you receive won't get you very far. They may make you feel good about yourself for a while, but it fades. Everyone wishes there was a little something different about them, whether that be a bigger chest or a smaller nose. Honestly, that is normal. But if you want to be truly happy, accept yourself for who you are. Don't let the unrealistic expectations of beauty in our society affect how you feel about yourself. Plus, one of the most attractive things about a women is her confidence!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I definitely agree with all the previous comments. Having a good role model/parent is such a huge part of who a girl becomes, and this doesn't necessarily have to just be in reference to beauty. It can also be in reference to health issues, faith, financial responsibility, eating habits, etc. A girl looks to her mother or whomever raised her from a very young age, and patterns and behaviors are ingrained in her as to what is "correct" and "appropriate" for a woman to do and be.

    One thing that my mother did when I was growing up is something that I will definitely do when I have children. She told me that she did this when I was little, and I really appreciated her for it. My mom is a beautiful woman, but she is not concerned with makeup or fashion or is by any means "fixy", and she'll be the first to tell you that. But a common compliment to little girls is that they are "beautiful", or "cute." That's usually the first thing that a stranger or family member or neighbor will say to a young girl. My mom, whenever anyone would make this comment about me when I was little, would pull me aside and say "you are beautiful, but you are also intelligent and athletic and talented..." or whatever the case may be. She would always compliment me on something other than my looks, which I think showed me at an early age that beauty was not the only thing that you can get complimented for. I will definitely do this for my children...

    ReplyDelete
  5. “America the Beautiful” had me fuming in some parts. The comments that some men made about the importance of a woman’s appearance left me appalled. I shudder to think about the role models they had, who made it perfectly okay to objectify and gawk at women the way that they do and to do it so unashamedly. I am even more saddened by the fact that their attitudes will likely be passed on to their offspring, and the mentality to judge harshly those individuals that do not fit the definition of beautiful as defined by society and the media. I do not know where the need for physical perfection comes from, but so many media outlets keep reiterating the message that you need to be thin and dress a certain way to be liked, appreciated, and taken seriously. It pains me to think of the rates of depression, suicide, eating disorders, plastic surgery decisions (and untimely deaths, at times) of those thinking they do not fit this definition. What angers me additionally are the magazine editors claiming they place these ads in their magazines to make a buck and to keep their jobs safe, although they understand the ramifications of what those ads portray. Why is everyone so incredibly focused on money? I want to ask them how they live with themselves, knowing that each dollar that gets placed in their back account is likely costing a woman her self-esteem and happiness.
    I struggle with my self-esteem and appearance to this day. I agree with someone’s comment in class about the necessity of having role models and family figures in your life that build you up, teach you the importance of loving yourself, and being happy with the way you look. Unfortunately, as much as I love my mother, she was also very subtly critical of me, weight-wise. She was not mean about it, but among the first things she’d ask during phone conversations while I was away at college was, “So, have you lost any weight? Have you gained any weight?” It hurt me for a long time, and still does. I know that when I have a daughter, I am going to tell her every single day that she is beautiful to me, and teach her the beauty of confidence. I’m not sure I have any words of wisdom since I struggle so much with my self-esteem still, but I think I would tell younger girls to smile. Smiling people are beautiful people, in my opinion. I would tell them that loving yourself can be hard, especially with the media messages we get bombarded with every day, but understand a different definition of beauty and strive towards it: confidence, strength, and compassion for others.
    Lastly, what fascinates me is the difference in the definition of beauty from place to place. I am Filipino, and since my childhood, the definition of beauty was long, black hair and snow white skin, in contrast to the US where it’s blonde hair and tanned skin. Even the products (moisturizers, soaps, face washes) in the Philippines are geared towards this! I am guilty of using these products by habit. Here is a commercial example: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HmdjN4_4E0Y.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I was so angry during the movie in class last week. The fact that a mother would allow a 12 year old child to be in that industry acting as an adult and encouraging her to miss so much school showing her that looks and what people think of you is more important than a basic education. I feel that this mother was simply forcing this life on her child so that she could live vicariously through the daughter and make up for her own failures as an aspiring model when she was younger. I believe that it is a mother’s job to make sure their children feel loved and valuable and protect them from the potential evils of the world and also encourage them to accomplish their dreams but to do so in an appropriate fashion and manner. There is absolutely no reason a 12 year old girl should be exposed to the evils present in high fashion modeling she is being taught that the only thing that is important are her looks and what the industry thinks of her. What happens when she gets older and her looks change or she gains weight and the industry decides she is no longer desirable? This girl has spent some of the most impressionable years of her life with people pumping her up and praising her for her looks but what happens when those praises stop, will she be able to find self satisfaction in herself without the constant affirmation of others of her worth?

    In class we talked about how you need to learn to love yourself before you can fully be happy and love others. I think that is one of the most important things about your teenage years. In middle school everyone is going through their own personal awkward stages and trying to find themselves and sadly that is when other kids can me the most cruel but if you are able to make it through that and get past it then I feel that is when you truly learn to love yourself and accept yourself for who you are and what personal attributes you can bring that are unique to you. But if you never have the chance to figure out what makes you special and what a great gift those things are then how can you truly love yourself and lead a full life.

    Over the weekend I happened to watch the movie Eat, Pray, Love and it really reminded me of a lot of things we have been talking about in this class. I really identified with Julia Robert’s character when she is talking about how she has lost her passion for food. I feel like I’m always eating the same thing and eating things that I feel like I should be eating instead of things I’m really excited about eating and I couldn’t help but ask myself why. What I realized was it all goes back to what we have been talking about in regards to body image and what we think society expects of us. And I realize now how stupid that is but it’s not like a switch that you can just turn off and stop thinking what people care it comes from years of subconscious brainwashing from the media.

    ReplyDelete
  7. America the Beautiful was an eye opener. I cannot believe a 12 year old GIRL was allowed to be taken out of school to model. Although she may have looked confident, I think she will have psychological and self esteem issues later in life. I was in shock to see how her mother supported the traveling, missing school, and encouraging her to do the fashion shows. This girl will never be able to act or live like a young girl again because her life was consumed in the modeling world. The need for US physical perfection developed from magazines, media, television shows, and celebrities. This is an unattainable perfection that misleads so many young teenage girls. Unfortunately, these girls believe that this perfect body is real and that if this one person in the magazine has it, they should be able to get it just like them. This leads girls to dieting, exercising for the wrong reasons, and eating disorders. The girls in the magazine are smiling and giggling, which is portraying they are “happy”. Girls see this smile and assume that the girl is truly happy and they need to have her body to be happy like her.

    I think self esteem mostly comes from family. If your family loves you for who you are and they do not poke any fun, then you are likely to become more confident. They learn to become confident in who they are without any second guessing. Girls learn directly from their moms. If their moms have good self esteem, its easier for the girls to have better self esteem. If I had to provide any advice to a 6th grader, I would tell the girl to stay young as long as possible. I would explain they only have 15 years to be young but 50 years to be old. I would tell the girl take advantage of being young and explain to be herself, and not to fall into what anyone else thinks.

    It is shocking how much photo shop can change a body. I strongly believe the media must legally put a disclaimer in pictures that were photo shopped. This will give hope to girls that these bodies are not real and unattainable.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I agree completely with the nutritionist interviewed in the photoshopping video that a disclaimer should be put on all pictures that are photoshopped. Dietary supplements that make outlandish claims are required to have a disclaimer on them so why shouldn't these modified pictures! Not until you actually see the true photo directly next to the final photo can you really see what a misrepresentation of a real woman that these photo-shopped pictures truly are. It is not humanly possible for a woman or a man to be physically perfect like these photos are portraying.

    Regarding "America the Beautiful," one part that stuck out to me was when the young model said at school everyone used to call her a giraffe and make fun of her looks. But once she was labeled a model, society saw her as one of the most beautiful people in the world. A select few in the fashion industry and celebrities define what is beautiful. When asked, just like the men in the video, we can't even explain why skinny or tan or big breasts are beautiful. That is just what we are fed by the media.

    I think is important to teach girls at a young age about the false portrayal of women in the media. I agree with Lauren that we should steer away from only giving compliments about people's looks. We need to remind girls that they are beautiful because they are smart, funny, or talented. We have the right as women to define what makes us beautiful.

    ReplyDelete
  9. When watching "America the Beautiful" I was very surprised the one girl was 12 years old and modeling like an adult woman. This becomes a problem because women of any age may look at her, not knowing she is 12 years old, and think they are in some way not beautiful because they do not look like her or clothes do not fit them the way they fit her or models like her.

    Self esteem is a major player in how young women and girls view themselves in comparison to celebrities or models in magazines or on the runway. The media is definitely the number one culprit in contributing to low self esteem in young girls and women. Constant airbrushing or photoshopping gives the ILLUSION that these women and girls on magazines and in commercials are flawless and have no imperfections. Because of this, it is difficult to get positive messages through, to young girls especially, about beauty. We have to remind girls that the idea of beauty varies from culture to culture and person to person. There is not one right or wrong definition of beauty and "beauty is in the eye of the beholder."

    ReplyDelete
  10. I really find it interesting to see all the magazine ads that show outrageous women who are unattainable in beauty. All the magazines that had the "bad" ads were from more of the fashion or celebrity magazines. Growing up, my mom did not allow any of those magazines in the house. Looking back I am very happy she did that (and I will implement that with my own children)All the magazines we had were for cooking and guidepost. I never really felt like I should be "perfect" like models or try to dress like them since I never saw them on a daily basis. I don't care what advertising companies say about beauty selling. Those ads are hurting the self-esteem of women everywhere. The most interesting part of the movie was the professor who reported that people from Fiji drastically changing (rebelling, more eating disorders) once television was introduced to their island. It is not realistic to say "get rid of all media" but sometimes I wish we would. One of my favorite shows (my guilty pleasure) is America's Next Top Model. Even though all those girls are tall and skinny, there is also a transformation from ugly duckling to beauty queen. The most recent winner from the show is the most awkward person (very, very tall, gangly, shy)but she transforms in pictures. I think every woman should get their picture taken just like models so that they can see their true beauty that shines within.

    I'll I could say to a young girl struggling with body image is that true beauty comes within and those that don't see it are not worth your time. I really like Lauren's comment about how her mom praises other things besides beauty like intelligence and hard worker because really it is the intelligent and hard workers who I would like to surround myself with. They are the ones with true beauty.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Because we live in one of the heaviest states, I believe there is more to fear about the effect that media has on young women and children. The drastically airbrushed pictures are a goal of many overweight females in our state, and unfortunately that goal is all the more unattainable (at least by healthy methods). Its almost as if the media is setting women up for failure. There are probably many women that want to look like the models in the magazines, and when they put their whole heart into working out and eating right but still don’t look like the models, its easy to see where eating disorders and depression come into play. Unfortunately, in the United States it seems like a large part of self esteem stems from outer beauty. When I feel like I'm having a good hair day, I seem to feel more confident and outgoing, but if I'm having a horrible hair day where all I can do is put my hair up in a ponytail sometimes I feel less confident. Just little instances like this show how important outer beauty is to Americans and their self esteem.

    I also thought the men in the video "America the Beautiful" were disgusting. I amazed me that men want the blonde skinny girl with big breasts, but they don’t know why. And I know there are plenty of women that want the tall, dark, and handsome man as well. But how can you NOT know why you really prefer these specific types? If we don’t fit these standards, are others not going to find us attractive? It seems pretty easy to slip into the mindset that if others don’t think I'm beautiful, then why should I think I'm beautiful.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I agree with the nutritionist in the PhotoShop video saying that there should be a disclaimer on the modified images. Even though you may know that the pictures have been modified, you don't think of that when you are looking at the images of these "perfect" bodies. The first thing that comes to mind is "I wish I looked like that." I think some girls get so caught up in wanting to look like the images that they go down the path of destruction of eating disorders. I knew they took away blemishes in photos but I didn't realize they would take half of a thigh off to make a woman's leg look thinner. If there was a disclaimer, it would at least help to remind us that the picture is fake. I would love to see them stop modifying women's bodies in photos and ads but, in reality, I know that won't happen.

    I thought "America the Beautiful" was very interesting. I was appalled at the guys in the video talking about the physical appearance of women the way they were but I think it is a huge issue with both sexes. What girl wouldn't want a boyfriend/husband that looked like Brad Pitt. I feel like society as a whole is so caught up in physical appearance due to the media. Looks are becoming more important than character and morals which is a very scary thing. I also was shocked that the girl in the movie was only 12 years old. I think there should be an age limit so young girls are not getting pulled into this industry. You could tell that the modeling experience had corrupted this young girl and when she came back to school as a changed person, she could potentially corrupt other children.

    I agree with many others that happiness must come from within. You have to love yourself to be truly happy. I believe that self esteem or lack of self esteem, develops at a very young age. Everyone you are exposed to is going to affect what you think about yourself whether it's your family or friends. Words can be uplifting but can also be hurtful. I think it's important to compliment children (not just on physical appearance) at a young age because it is going to affect their self esteem as they grow up. My advice to a young girl would be to try not to let others' comments affect the way you view yourself (which is very hard to do). I would also say that being beautiful isn't just about appearance but more importantly about character, morals, and how you treat others.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I too found the men in America the beautiful appalling, but the mother of the 12 year old daughter was most outrageous. I got the sense she was living vicariously through her daughter as she had previously dabbled in modeling as well. What was quite interesting was how the perception of the young girl changed to someone who was beautiful when she was previously made fun of for her stature. It makes me think of all the "ugly duckling" type fairy tales and pretty princess culture that is marketed to very young girls. Only once someone is very "beautiful" does she get the prince, not get made fun of, etc etc. It's sad that self worth is not felt in those kind of characters until that physical transformation to something beautiful is made. I know there is an author who recently got a lot of heat for writing a book about the princess culture being pushed on to little girls. It will be interesting to see how that later affects their self esteem and just shows how early images of beauty are impressed upon very, very young girls.

    In regards to the magazine ads, ironically one of my roommates was reading a magazine in which the Chanel perfume ad was right in the front and she commented on how pointless the model's nudity is. It's not just us who notice! I think its good to keep that conversation going with the women around us about the absurdity of many images marketed.

    ReplyDelete
  14. In the youtube videos aboce, I find it quite humorous that to make their point about how photoshopped images are skewing our cultures perceptions, they used a woman who in my view has already achieved this culture's perfect body. She works out all the time, she had a slim waist, slender legs, so on and so forth...so I think they picked the wrong person to make their point. While I can see the differences that photoshop made, I don't think that there was anything wrong with the initial pictures. I think the dove commercial that we saw in class made a better point of it because the woman came into the studio almost haggard looking and came out like a million dollars. The dove commercial also showed the NUMEROUS modifications made by both make-up and photoshop to illustrate their point. While I don't think these youtube videos were off-base, I think the dove commercials hit more of a "homerun." They made it quite clear to the audience that the images you see on commercials, billboards, or wherever are adulterations of the original to sell something unattainable for 99%+ of the population.

    ReplyDelete