Tuesday, March 1, 2011

Class #6 - Domestic Violence

Today we heard about the Indiana Coalition Against Domestic Violence from Caryn Burton, Director of training for ICADV.  Once again, we are asked not to judge but to help.  "Why don't they just leave?" becomes a very tough question to answer.  Some people can look back into the individual's life and think - they just did not receive enough love as a child' or 'they hard a very hard life growing up'. 

Important to understand is that this is about violence and you cannot love someone else enough to make it go away.  As we discussed with eating disorders - you have to love yourself and respect  yourself - self-love comes from the individual and others cannot love you enough to make up for whatever is going on.  The cycle of violence continues. 

You will find yourself at some time in your life looking at a relationship and thinking - this does not look good or I don't like the sound of what I am hearing.  I hope you will be at the right place and time to listen and refer the individual to help or before it goes too far - to suggest that the relationship does not sound healthy.  Have you had any such opportunities so far?  What questions do you have?  Any comments to share?  Again post anonymously if you wish.

16 comments:

  1. http://www.icadvinc.org/

    website for ICADV

    ReplyDelete
  2. I also encourage you to suggest the titles of films, books or songs that deal with domestic violence topics.
    Films: Jennifer Lopez in "Enough"
    "Burning Bed" with Farrah Faucett
    "Sleeping with the Enemy" with Julia Roberts
    "Double Jeopardy" with Ashley Judd
    "Carosel" Rogers and Hammerstein classic

    Songs:
    Goodbye Earl - Dixie Chicks
    Because of You

    What do these say about domestic violence in our society? Do you want to add to the list?

    ReplyDelete
  3. I found the lecture today to be very powerful and very sad... It unfortunately brought to mind several women that I have known to be in physically or emotionally abusive relationships. I think it's important to remember that these relationships don't start out abusive - the batterer is typically not hitting the woman or screaming at her from Date 1, when it's easy to leave. Instead, the actions start off subtle and get worse over time, as the relationship develops and the victim has invested more and more of herself, so it's so hard for them to leave.

    I personally do not feel in any way qualified to help a person who is being abused, but I am going to make myself a copy of numbers to contact so that if necessary I can refer a person to a shelter or have an idea of who to call for help.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I loved how passionate our speaker was. I think it is really important to try to understand the dynamics of an abusive relationship and what is going on inside the victim’s mind to be able to be the most helpful to them. It can be very difficult if you have not been in that situation to understand why a person would stay in such a destructive relationship but I think our speaker did a great job of explaining all the aspects of domestic abuse.

    There is a song I really like by Destiny’s Child called “Story of Beauty.” It tells the story of a young girl that is sexually abused by her step father and because of that she thought all she had to offer was her body. I think it is a really great song because it really takes the victim’s side and emphasizes that it is not her fault and that she is beautiful.
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QhyJ14u4tAY

    Other songs:
    The Little Girl – John Michael Montgomery
    Independence Day – Martina Mcbride
    Concrete Angel – Martina Mcbride

    ReplyDelete
  5. Domestic violence is heart wrenching. I used to think the victim should just leave and get out of the relationship. If I hear of any domestic altercation, my first response is , why does she just not leave? I always knew it was easier said than done, but class yesterday made me realize how it truly is really difficult to get out of a violent relationship, especially when children are involved. I am glad that Caryn gave us brochures with outreach programs that we can use if we ever need to, either for a friend or working as a pharmacist).
    Before yesterday, I have never seen the music video to "Love the way you Lie" by Rhianna. I was shocked when we watched it, because I was not expecting it to be so realistic and violent. There was a part where the women handed a beer to the guy and my initial thought was how could you encourage him to continue to abuse. However, it clearly portrays the viscous cycle of abuse. When I was younger, "Goodbye Earl" was my best friend and mine favorite song. At the time, we would just scream it on the top of our lungs and had no idea what the lyrics meant. I decided to watch the music video because I have never seen it. The video is realistic because the women can file for a divorce but the man will still follow her. We learned that 75% of murders happen after the women ends the relationship. This video was not as graphic as Rhianna's but still they promoted to murder the abusive ex-husband.

    ReplyDelete
  6. What I found most interesting about this topic was how many times women do not leave these relationships so that they can take care of their kids. I have never thought of it that way. I just though they could take the kids and leave as simple as that. I have never been in that kind of relationship before, but now I realize why my mother always fretted about what boys took interest in me. To have someone so manipulative and domineering as an intimate partner is quite scary and unfathomable.
    What is interesting is that this doesn't just happen in the U.S. I remember studying abroad in Mexico and the big news was that the wife was killed by her husband and they were very well-to-do and rich. I wonder if there is more domestic violence in certain cultures than others. I would assume there would be especially in cultures where the husband's word is law.
    There are many references to domestic violence in the media and the majority of them end in death. I do not know if there is a safe way to severe ties with the abusive partner besides death. A great example of this (and a great movie) is Fried Green Tomatoes. Also the play Streetcar Named Desire which depicts domestic violence as desire (similar to Rhianna's song).

    ReplyDelete
  7. I also found this lecture to be very sad and informative. I have never been in an abusive relationship or situation, so it was powerful to hear a survivor’s perspective; one of the things that really stuck out to me was that Caryn always referred to the abused person as a survivor and not a victim. I remember seeing the movie “Enough” in theaters, and I found it to be very disturbing. It’s much different hearing about stories of abuse and actually seeing them in a movie or music video. I think “Enough” did a good job of showing the process of abuse: the husband started out to be doting and protective which progressed to jealousy and possessiveness. He also tried to use their daughter and his money as leverage to force the wife to stay. One scene I always remember from the movie is when Jennifer Lopez’s character goes to the police station, they tell her she should get a restraining order, and she asks what good a piece of paper will do. I have always wondered the same thing: if an abuser comes after someone, what good will a restraining order do in the immediate situation? Because of the isolation abused people experience, their perceived lack of help getting out of the relationship, and the fact that the majority of murders associated with abuse occur after the person leaves the situation help me to see why an abused person would stay under such horrible circumstances. I would be extremely interested to go to one of the recovery group meetings that abusers can attend because I think it would help me to better see the mindset and motivation of an abuser.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I am really glad we had this speaker on domestic violence. I never really understood the depth of it because I have never known anyone that has went through this (or at least that I know about). I'm sure there are people that I know in this situation but I would imagine they don't want it known. I didn't realize there were so many aspects to domestic violence such as the economic abuse and psychological abuse. I had always thought of domestic violence as physical abuse and verbal abuse. Unfortunately our speaker has experienced domestic violence because no one should have to go through that but I am glad she could share her story with us and others to raise awareness. Having gone through it I think helped her make us understand it. It wasn't just like a lecture with bullet points but she had real life examples of everything. For example, the slide said one of the parts of power and control was "isolation" but she made the term understandable when she said that the batterer will destroy the relationship between a woman and her best friend or family.

    I feel like I have a better understanding of domestic violence. I do think that you have to experience it to truly understand it but I feel like I could help lead someone in the right direction if they were going through domestic violence. I am glad we have brochures and resources to be able to give to someone that might need it.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I am very glad that we had the chance to listen to Caryn speak about an issue that was obviously very dear to her. Her knowledge and connection to the issue spoke very loudly to me. What hit me the hardest was truly listening to "Love the Way You Lie." I cannot even count how many times I have sang along with that song on the radio and never even gave a second thought to the words I was repeating. I was absolutely disgusted when I paid attention to the lyrics and watched the video. How many adolescents and teens are out there just like me singing to these songs and actually believing what these supposed role models are saying. I will definitely take more care in what music I listen to after this lecture and what message they are actually portraying.

    The other piece of information that really grabbed me was when Caryn discussed how important it is for the survivor to get out of the relationship when they are ready and that they may be staying in the relationship because it is "safer" than leaving. I had never thought about someone staying in an abusive relationship because it was safer than leaving and the statistic that 75% of women murdered because of domestic violence are murdered after they leave really proved that. Before this presentation, I would have thought it would be the right thing to do to turn in the batterer myself if the victim wouldn't themselves.

    Like Angela said, I also do not feel comfortable giving advice to someone being abused but would really like to have some of the brochures that were passed out as resources at my pharmacy.

    ReplyDelete
  10. As others have said before me, I am glad we had the opportunity to hear Caryn speak. She was passionate and informative, and her strength to rise above her personal situation to be an advocate for others is amazing. It makes me sad to think that there is still a fair amount of people whose stories don't quite end as well as Caryn's. Domestic violence has so many intricacies. As a person who naively thought it was all physical and that a woman could just simply get up and leave if she wanted, I have definitely seen the reality of it all. It is truly so complex and such a vicious cycle is perpetuated if there is no intervention. I will definitely be more observant and proactive in offering resources for help, should the situation ever present itself. It could easily be the difference between life and death.
    Christina Aguilera has a song entitled "I'm OK" that talks about her experience as a child witnessing the domestic violence inflicted by her father on her mother: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=quAFmNvk_Zs.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Just as everyone else has already said, I too am glad that Caryn could come talk to our class about domestic violence and share her own story with us. Her discussion definitely made me think about the way that media portrays domestic violence. When I was younger, I used to LOVE the song "Goodbye Earl" because it was catchy. I never stopped to think about the story the lyrics were telling. But, even before watching the music video in class, I always switched the radio station when "Love the Way you Lie" came on. I found the words disgusting. So many young teenagers look up to Rihanna and Eminem, I just wish that the song had a different spin to it. Yes, it brings light to domestic violence as an issue, but I don’t think it makes adolescents think twice about actions.

    I also thought it was important that Caryn discussed how domestic violence is prevalent in all ages/races/socioeconomic status etc… I guess before class, I thought domestic violence was more of an "adult issue". But Caryn's experience obviously showed this is not true. I think that technology is "fueling the fire" in domestic violence. Just like we talked about in class, technology gives an easy excuse for a jealous partner to get angry. I had a friend in high school who wasn’t allowed to have any boy's phone numbers in her phone, and her boyfriend would check to make sure that she wasn't calling/texting anyone else. So to get around this rule, she hid a little slip of paper with phone numbers on it underneath the battery cover of her cell phone. Before class, I never realized how little jealous actions like this, could actually be a much bigger issue.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I have been made aware of domestic violence from a very young age. My mother was physically abused in her first marriage, prior to marrying my father. She got married at 17 to a MUCH older man who quickly began to abuse her. Because of my mother's experience, my sister and I have always been taught to be strong women, and never put up with anything in a relationship that you don't want to - whether it be physical or emotional. My mother is the strongest, most amazing woman I know, and I really look up to her. I think if something like that could happen to her, it could happen to almost anyone.

    I was really surprised to find that domestic violence is not just physical abuse, but emotional abuse as well. I also found it interesting just how predictable a man's behavior is when he is an abuser. For example, the first thing he will try to do is cut ties between a woman's friends and then family. That is exactly what my best friend's boyfriend in high school did. Making women aware of these signs is an important part of preventing violent relationships.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I thought that this was a great discussion. Domestic Violence has been something that I have heard a lot about since coming to college through my sororities philantropy and other avenues. I have also volunteered at the Julian Center several times. I enjoyed out speaker and thought that she brought an interesting light to the topic of domestic violence. I appreciated how she used her own personal story to break the stereotypes of what most people think about domestic violence. I hadn't ever watched the eminem and rihanna video all the way through, and I think it would be interesting to see Rihanna's comments and her motivation for singing such a song, especially since she has been involved in public domestic violence problems. I can't imagine why she would participate in a song like that, but, of course, that is her personal choice.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Caryn was a great speaker with an especially passionate perspective of this topic. I think until someone experiences the emotions the victims undergo its impossible to really understand. There are so many factors, as demonstrated by that wheel, that it seems to be an extremely complicated relationship between the victim and the abuser. Despite warning signs, I still think it would be hard to predict that someone who supposedly loves you could turn abusive.

    As mentioned above, I think this would be something really difficult to discuss with someone who needed help. Having the numbers is a good idea because at least being a resource is something I could do.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I really enjoyed listening to Caryn speak about domestic violence, especially since she has had personal experience with it. I was in G.E.A.R. (Greeks as Educators, Advocates, and Resources) here on campus and we were the designated members of our respective greek houses that students could come to if they needed advice, someone to talk to, or recommendations for resources for any life problems including eating disorders, sexual assault, and domestic violence. I had listened to the basics of domestic violence and was informed on how to guide students to the right resources but never really understood how much of an impact I could really have on such a situation. Listening to Caryn talk about all the reasons of why women/men stay in violent relationships helped me have a greater understanding of how to better discuss options with victims or talk to them without sounding judgmental.

    It was an interesting moment when I realized that I would sing the "Love the Way You Lie" song without even realize what the words were about and the message that was being conveyed. The video was especially difficult to watch because it made the lyrics come to life. I think some songs about victims that have survived domestic violence can be empowering but we don't realize how many songs glorify violent behavior. I definitely will be more conscious of paying attention to the actual lyrics instead of focusing on the music, especially since so many people may be offended by such songs.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I found this lecture to be very sobering to think that domestic violence would be as prevalent as it is. I also thought the song/video that was played of Eminem and Rihanna was sending the wrong signals to the public about domestic violence. I think this lecture will help me better understand and communicate to victims of domestic violence and hopefully I will be able to encourage them to seek help.
    I found it interesting how there were different types of domestic violence (as seen in the chart she presented) as opposed to just physical and verbal violence. It's sad to think that one person in a relationship could be so controlling as to leave a person destitute if they ever tried to leave the abusive relationship. I think it would be interesting to do some studies to see what kind of factors are consistently found in individuals who are perpetrators of domestic violence. Maybe by finding a few commonalities between most/all perpetrators, it could be possible to at least diminish the likelihood of it occurring.

    ReplyDelete