Saturday, March 26, 2011

Class #8 - Breast Cancer Issues and BRCA considerations

We had 2 speakers to the class on March 22nd.  Lisa Hayes shared her experiences with a diagnosis of breast cancer at a time when she was not insured.  She has a very positive attitude and turned her experience into an opportunity to serve other women through programming at the Gennesaret Free Clinic.  Do you have any additional questions for her?  Did you have any experience like with her daughters?  Many young women when diagnosed will try to shield her family from her fears - not really talk about issues with their husband and make make it see like no big deal for her family. Is this good or could it be a problem?  We also had a speaker - Dr. Enz - who had a big decision to make regarding finding out whether she wanted to know about her BRCA status.  Given her family history it is not surprising but it is a big question to ask and a even bigger issue to act upon.  Do you have any questions or thoughts on the BRCA information?  What would you do?

12 comments:

  1. Talking with Dr. Enz really made me think about whether or not I would want to know if I had the BRCA gene. I think I would only want to find out after I had gotten a diagnosis of cancer to be able to use it as a tool on my approach to treatment options but I don’t think I would like to know before then. I totally understand why her sister would choose not to get tested herself yet because at that point I feel like you would just be waiting for cancer if you found out you had the BRCA gene. Because of their strong family history they are already aware of their increased need for vigilant screening which increases their likelihood of finding any cancer in early stages. After a diagnosis of cancer I thing I would do the same as Dr. Enz and just have everything removed in hopes of decreasing the risk of cancer returning in another location.

    In regards to our discussion with Lisa about trying to shield her family from the pains of cancer, it made me thing of a close family friend that died of breast cancer. This woman was my grandmother’s best friend and did not tell anyone (not any friends or even a single member of her family) about her diagnosis until a week before she died from the cancer because she did not want to burden her family with the stress of her cancer diagnosis and knew that she personally did not want to receive treatment for her condition and simply wanted to enjoy to the fullest her time left. Ever since then I have always wondered how incredibly difficult it must have been to keep secret something so huge and not be able to reach out to those you love most for comfort. I feel women now have such high expectations of themselves to be strong and hold their family together causing them to put themselves last once everyone else’s needs are met.

    ReplyDelete
  2. It is definitely easier for those who work in healthcare, and have a greater understanding of the ins and outs of the system, to be more involved in their treatment. It is a scary situation for any woman (or man) who is diagnosed with breast cancer, but I'm sure those who have no knowledge of the disease state and the options available for treatment feel they have almost no control of their health. At first I couldn't believe that Lisa said some of the women she worked to help say that would rather not know if they have cancer or not and would rather "wait it out." If it were me, I would rather know all of my options right away. But now that I think about it, I can understand why some women would rather just not know. This is why the work that Lisa Hayes does to help and protect these women is truly amazing.

    I had no idea that Dr. Enz was a survivor of breast cancer. If it were me in her situation, I would have also wanted to know if I had the BRCA gene. However, if I had a daughter, her health would always be in the back of my mind if I knew I was positive for the gene. I would also be worried about how I would tell her about the importance of knowing that she might carry the gene. I wouldn't want her to live her life constantly afraid that she might get cancer, but I would want her to understand that she should be more aware about her health.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I had never really given much thought to some regimens of chemotherapy causing infertility in women. I think it is easy to say that I would want to treat my cancer as aggressively as possible in order for the highest chances of a cure, but knowing that I might never have children may change my views. If I was in Dr. Enz's shoes, with children and an established family, I would definitely have done the same thing in order to prolong my life as long as possible. I am not sure whether her sister was married or had children, but I could understand not wanting to know about the BRCA gene if you did not yet have a family.

    I have learned through the past few guest speakers and through people I know that these life threatening diseases do not discriminate. I wanted to share this link of a girl I went to all of grade school and high school with who was diagnosed with breast cancer at age 19. As Lisa said, it is very important to at the very least to be self aware of our breasts and any changes starting NOW.

    http://www.clicker.com/tv/today-show/young-breast-cancer-survivor-is-honored-436139/

    ReplyDelete
  4. I was very happy we had a talk on breast cancer mainly because I do not know much about it. No one in my family has had breast cancer that I know of, but I always see the pink ribbons and wonder what survivors go through. Lisa just astounded me. She seemed so level headed and calm through her process even though she was probably going insane inside. If I was in her situation, I would want to know what type of breast cancer I had. If I had a family history like Dr. Enz, I would want to know if I had the BRCA gene so to better protect myself and my daughters.

    I think it would be interesting to get the opinion of a single lady with breast cancer or a lady before children. It seems an easy choice to remove everything if you are in a stable relationship and already are finished having kids, but I wonder whether women who have not yet started a family would want a more conservative approach. I wonder how breast cancer effects the intimate lives of single women compared to married women. We always hope that nothing bad will happen to us, but as women, breast cancer will effect our lives or the life of a close relative or friend. I was almost speechless to see Dr. Enz speak because I had no idea she was a breast cancer survivor. As a girl, my mother tried to talk to me about self checking myself, but it is not until now (when I'm older and in a health care field) that I realize how important it is to educate all women starting at a young age. Thanks mom!

    ReplyDelete
  5. One thing that surprised me from our breast cancer lecture was that 90% of women with breast cancer have no family history. I have never really worried that much about breast cancer because no one in my family has a history, but now I know that family history is only one small risk factor. If I had a family history of breast cancer, however, I would want to know if I had the BRCA gene so I could be proactive. My nurse practitioner who is in her early 40s found out she was positive for the BRCA gene a few years ago, and she decided to have a double mastectomy because, like Dr. Enz, she said it wasn’t a matter of if but when she would be diagnosed with breast cancer. If I was positive for the BRCA gene and had children, especially daughters, I think I would always be frightened about what that would mean for their health. From what both Lisa and Dr. Enz explained as well as stories from women I know who have been sick (with breast cancer or another serious illness), it seems like women almost always put on a strong front to shield their families and friends from the reality of the situation as much as possible. Joann Hofer-Varela (our speaker on heart disease in women) described a similar experience of keeping some of her fears from her family so they would not fret as much about her being worried. I think covering up some information is probably a natural reaction for some women and may not necessarily be a bad thing because it can allow them to feel more in control of how others perceive them (i.e, not just “the sick person”); however, I think it is important that there is some form of a support group where women can really vent all of their fears and talk about their aches a pains, whether it be with other women with similar experiences, a friend, a parent, or a significant other.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I have a friend who is BRCA + and was diagnosed with breast cancer at age 26, so this lecture was particularly interesting. One thing that my friend has shared with me was how much the mastectomy, oophorectomy, and reconstructive surgeries affected her body image - this of course would be difficult for anyone, but particularly younger women. After seeing the struggles she went through with reconstruction, including multiple Pseudomonas infections, it is hard to say what I would do in her situation, as the decision to get a mastectomy is much more than a simple medical decision.

    My friend has suggested that in some ways, being a younger survivor has made her recovery easier - she felt she had more to fight for than an older person might, particularly since at the time of her diagnosis her daughter was only a baby.

    ReplyDelete
  7. It is inspirational that Lisa has used her breast cancer experience to be an advocate for women going through a similar experience. She serves as a voice for patients who are oftentimes voiceless and cannot find words in such a confusing, shocking situation. In terms of her wanting to make her diagnosis not seem like a big deal, I think it's simply a mother's innate desire to nurture and shield her family from things that could be emotionally hurtful. It's selfless to want to make things seem as normal as possible for people you don't want to scare with foreboding, medical jargon. At the same time, however, nothing compares to the support system a family undoubtedly provides in a time of crisis or need. I think it would be difficult to find a balance. If I had been in Dr. Enz's shoes with such a family history, I would have been terrified to find out if I had the BRCA gene. Like someone before me mentioned, it would seem like I was "waiting for cancer." However, I think I would ultimately want to prepare myself and attempt to be as proactive in implemplenting prophylactic measures. I can understand the issues women wrestle with, though. Does one live in fear of developing breast cancer knowing she is BRCA positive? Or does one choose not to know, and then decide to fight that battle should it present itself?
    Christina Applegate, an actress I'm sure everyone knows, had a double mastectomy a couple of years ago. She is also BRCA positive and recently had a baby girl. She is definitely one of those women who never let the diagnosis stop her, and is now working to help others in the same situation. I think her story would be an interesting one to read.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I was glad that breast cancer was the topic this week because my brother's girlfriends mother just got diagnosed last week and we just learned breast cancer in Therapeutics. These two women were very inspirational because they survived the battle against breast cancer. I think it is amazing that Lisa is helping other women diagnosed with breast cancer because women need all the support they can get to help deal with overcoming cancer. I did not know that Dr. Enz, a professor we've had for 3 years, had breast cancer, which shows that anyone can be a survivor. I thought it was brave for Dr. Enz to determine if she was BRCA positive or negative. If I was in Dr. Enz's situation, I would want to know my BRCA status to do everything in my power to eradicate the breast cancer. It must be difficult to have daughters knowing that you are BRCA positive. Would you get them tested for BRCA? At what age?

    ReplyDelete
  9. I loved having Lisa and Dr.Enz come talk to our class about surviving breast cancer. I haven't had much contact with cancer survivers, so it was nice to hear their personal stories. I think it is amazing that Lisa was able to fight her cancer, and then find the strength/courage to make a major career change to help others that find themselves in the same situation she used to be in. I also think that she approached her diagnosis in the right manner in terms of how she shared it with her family. She said that she tried to make things as "normal" as possible at home and really worked with all of her doctors to keep her important dates open. Even though she kept things "normal", she never mentioned that she hid information from her family in anyway to protect them, and I think this important. I think I would feel more comfortable talking with my family about my cancer/feelings/fears, not to burden them, but to make sure every one is on the same page and to know that I wasn't alone in my battle. I'm not sure what I would do if I were in Dr. Enz's shoes. I'm assuming I would want/need to know if I had the BRCA gene if there was any reason to think I did. Like Dr.Enz, I worry about anything and everything. I think that I wouldn’t be able to sleep at night until I knew for sure whether I had the gene. Now, I have NO idea what I would do if I found out that I did have the BCRA gene. I guess it would depend on my age/family status/health etc.


    Also, I liked the information that was presented to us in the power-point at the beginning of class. We learned about Inflammatory Breast Cancer during the power point, which was not taught in our therapeutics lecture. I just found out today that one of my friend's mother has relapsed for the second time with this type of cancer. She just finished 6 rounds of chemotherapy a couple of months ago, and all of the cancer came back, so now she is scheduled for 4 more rounds of chemotherapy within 4 weeks. Her doctor said that this is only the second case of Inflammatory Breast Cancer that he has seen in the last 15 years. I'm glad that I have a little more knowledge on the subject since it is so rare and we weren't taught it in our other class.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I really enjoyed the discussion on breast cancer. I didn't know much about it until we discussed it in Therapeutics but hearing the personal experiences really put things in perspective. From what I had heard in the past, it seemed like breast cancer was mostly because of a family history. Now, I know that family history is only a small risk factor. Cancer (not breast cancer) does run in my family and it is scary to not know what is coming in the future. I think if the BRCA gene was in the family, I would want to know because I would just worry about whether or not I had it. If I was the type of person that didn't worry about everything and could live a normal life without thinking about the possible future, I don't think I would want to know about the BRCA gene but being the worrier that I am, I would want to know. I think picking a treatment and possibly surgery would be such a hard decision, especially if I did not have children yet. I've dreamed about being a mother for a very long time and I don't know if I could let something take that away from me.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Breast cancer is a topic that I find difficult to fully understand the emotional and psychological effects of because I clearly do not have an attachment to my breast tissue (however miniscule my amount may be). I think for a man to best understand it, he must think in terms of testicular or prostate cancer in order to grasp the kind of emotional struggle a woman would face with a similar breast cancer diagnosis. I think if I had the opportunity to discover whether I was a carrier for a testicular or prostate cancer gene, I would take the test. I think I lean towards this decision because if my father had that kind of cancer, I would want to know whether I am genetically prone to getting it as well. While this could potentially give me an amount of paranoia about the cancer's possibility of arising, I would rather know and therefore be more vigilant against the cancer. Likewise, if my fiance had the opportunity to take the BRCA test because of a potential family history of breast cancer, I would appreciate her doing so. Ultimately, I would leave the decision in her hands, but I think the extra vigilance could help catch any would be tumors and therefore prove its worth in gold.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I too was surprised to learn that 90% of breast cancer patients had no family history. I admit to being somewhat relieved that there is no history of breast cancer in my family, but apparently that doesn't get you off the hook! Its hard to say what I would choose if faced with a choice to learn if I was BRCA2 positive or not. I feel like either set of worries would drive me crazy- worrying about not know or worrying about getting breast cancer if I did know. I think Dr. Enz was both very brave and wise to undergo all the treatment she did given her family history.

    We are lucky women like Lisa take up a cause to help people. She seems like such a tough woman to endure all the treatment and still put on a bright face to take her daughter to college.

    I am always amazed by the strength breast cancer survivors seem to possess. I do not imagine myself to be so graceful in handling that.

    ReplyDelete