Thursday, April 21, 2011
4-12-2011 Infertility
Please provide comments or questions form the materials on Infertility as provided by Dr. Richey-Smith. What questions remain in your mind? Once again - this is an area where medicine and religion mix. This is an area where you might be wise to investigate a little on the guidance from major church groups so you are prepared for questions that might arise. Is this are area I should explore more next year - that is - the interface of religion and modern therapeutics?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I was very excited that Dr. Richey-Smith came in and talked with us in such a candid way. It seems like infertility is such a "taboo" topic, even though so many women struggle with it. Obviously, it is a very persoanal struggle between a couple, but we have learned so much in this class about how effective support groups and such really do help women (and men) who are going through a specific disease/condition, and infertility would be just as applicable of a topic. I had never heard or discussed any of the procedures or drug therapies in class before, so that was also beneficial to be able to hear about.
ReplyDeleteThe woman I interviewed for my paper struggled with infertility issues for a very long time, and her story of pain, anguish, and depression broke my heart. The determination in her words was inspiring, and I'm happy to say that she and her husband were successful nearly 28 years ago. It was so interesting to have my interviewee's perspective of the provision of health care related to infertility 30 years ago to compare to Dr. Richey-Smith's story in the current times. My interviewee mentioned how she oftentimes felt, back then, that some people she went to see were often insensitive to her rollercoaster of emotions. I think it's important as health care practitioners, as well as just in regular life, to be mindful of the plight that others endure and consider how a patient might understand things. I definitely think the interface with religion and therapeutics should be explored! It would help to have some working knowledge so as to not inadvertently offend someone, as well as be able to provide therapeutic options that are applicable.
ReplyDeleteI can't image what it would feel like to know that if I wanted to have a child I would have to go through an experience like Dr. Richey-Smith's. Besides being emotionally exhausting, treating infertility is still not guaranteed to work. After hearing her speak on the topic, I started to think about the women who have difficulty getting pregnant but cannot afford to have infertility treatments. The tests required to confirm that either the male or female in the relationship are infertile is enough to deplete the average couple's savings. If they can't afford infertility treatments, adoption is another option, but it is expensive too! Many people have limited options. I am glad that we were able to listen to Dr. Richey-Smith's personal experience and insight into infertility. You can clearly see that she is so passionate about the topic and wants to help others understand the ins and outs of the treatment process as well as comfort these couples with her own experiences.
ReplyDeleteInfertility has always been a topic of interest because it cold happen to any woman and they not know it until they try to have children. One of my cousins could never have children but they did not have the money to try fertility treatments. My interviewee for this class was my boyfriend's mother and how she had in-vitro for his younger brother. It really seems that infertility affects at least one person you know if not more. I am interested to see what religions are totally against in-vitro. It did sound weird to me that (according to Dr. Richey)that adoption and in-vitro were about the same price. I think that would be another interesting topic to explore is comparing in-vitro with adoption and the couples' experiences.
ReplyDeleteSeveral have left comments about religious views and infertility . This is a link to a website with more information. Or you can do a Google search with "religious view on assisted reporduciton".
ReplyDeleteHere is a start
http://www.ivf-worldwide.com/Education/ivf-global-perspective-religious.html
It was really interesting to hear Dr. Richey-Smith’s story of personal struggle with fertility issues. Infertility seems especially difficult because even with treatment nothing is guaranteed; it would be devastating to want a child and spend thousands of dollars, but still not be able to conceive. My aunt and uncle struggled with not being able to have children for many years. After trying many of the treatment options Dr. Richey-Smith mentioned, my aunt and uncle decided to adopt. About a year and a half after adopting a son, my aunt found out she was pregnant, so now they have a biological son as well. I don’t believe my aunt or uncle were part of an organized support group, but I know they talked with other friends who were going through the same struggles. It’s such a personal and heart-breaking condition, so I believe having a support group would be very helpful. The online groups Dr. Richey-Smith mentioned seemed like they could be valuable resources to tell patients about.
ReplyDeleteI was extremely impressed by Dr. Richey-Smith's courage to come talk to us about such a personal issue. I find it very inspiring that she has decided to take her experiences and turn it into a learning experience for women and health care professionals. I was very glad that we addressed this topic in class because it is not something most women like to talk about. I have an aunt who was never able to conceive even after fertility treatments and later decided to adopt. For several holidays, she was unable to stay at my grandparents' home because my other aunt & uncle had a small baby and she was not emotionally ready to be around children. Another friend had a still birth and had to undergo fertility treatments to get pregnant again. She blogged about her journey and was part of several support groups in the area which seemed very therapeutic. I would have liked if we went a little deeper into the different medical procedures available because I do not feel like I could give an adequate description of them to women with questions. With a large percentage of women suffering from some sort of infertility problem, I think this topic was very relevant.
ReplyDeleteInfertility has been an interesting topic to me, because my cousin struggled a lot in getting pregnant and had several miscarriages. I think that it must be very frustrating to watch other people get pregnant, especially if they accidentally get pregnant and/or don't seem to take care of their children very well, all while an infertile couple is doing everything in their power to have a baby. I also think it would be really hard if a couple had been using contraceptives for years before trying to conceive, only to realize that all along they've been infertile.
ReplyDeleteI knew that fertility options were expensive, but I'd had no idea that they were *that* expensive! It was also really helpful to learn about other treatment options besides IVF, as IVF is what I hear about most commonly in the media.
I too was amazed at the "price" Dr. Richey said affectionately of her daughter. It seems unimaginable to me now to have that kind of money to spend on anything, but I imagine it would have been worth every penny. Dr. Richey was brave to share her experience. Overall, I think its just been so interesting to have the women come into our class and speak openly about private health issues. Nothing to be ashamed of in any of them, but it would be difficult I think to open up to students and strangers. I think that was one of the wonderful things about this class. The environment for other women to do that and the opportunity for us to listen.
ReplyDeleteI was very interested in Dr. Richey-Smith's story about infertility. Infertility is such a touchy subject because it can be very personal and upsetting. It is extremely unfortunate for any woman to have to experience infertility. Dr. Richey-Smith took charge and did everything she could to have child. I actually am really interested in learning more about infertility issues because of her lecture and how much she has done. Some women are not as lucky as Dr. Richey and have no other options except for adoption. However, I am a strong supporter of adoption and think it is a great option for anyone. To be completely honest, I have no idea which religions do or do not approve of in vito. But I think it is important to have somewhat of idea because this topic can rudely and emotionally upset a couple if something is miscommunicated . Also, I always thought in vitro was more expensive then adoption so I found that surprising that they were about the same cost.
ReplyDeleteI was very excited for this topic since this one of the main reasons I wanted to take this class. My cousin has been going through fertility issues and it just made me realize that I knew nothing about infertility treatments. It’s always great to see the happy ending that can come after a struggle with a particular medical condition. Dr. Richey-Smith did a great job of explaining both causes and potential solutions. I think exploring the role of religion in fertility issues and other women’s health issues in generally is definitely something that would be beneficial to add into the curriculum for this course for next year. I think this course does a great job of integrating the facts with real life patient experiences and feelings and I think that religion can be a very big part of that for many women and play a big role in their decision making process.
ReplyDeleteI am really glad we discussed this issue. We don't discuss infertility at all in any of our other classes and it is something pretty prominent in today's society (especially with women waiting until they are older to get married and have children). I am very impressed that Dr. Richey could be so open with this issue and she did a good job of discussing her thoughts but not saying that what she did is right for everyone. I personally have struggled in deciding whether in-vitro is against my morals or not. I understand that people desperately want to have their own children and that this technology has helped many couples but I don't really like the idea of fertilizing multiple eggs and throwing away those that are not needed (if too many eggs get fertilized).
ReplyDelete