PCOS: We discussed the pathophysiology and treatment of PCOS and heard from a patient who has had the disorder for about 10 years. What are your thoughts? What if you were suddenly afflicted with a disorder that increased your weight by 50–100#? Normal kids gather for Pizza and Soda (neither can be considered as low carb options). How would that have affected your high school and college friendships?
What do you think about this disorder that can affect diet choices, weight gain, relationships and incur the “judgment” of by-standers. There are challenges to living with it but as we understand it more – it is rarely associated with infertility when under control. Do you understand Glycemic Index a bit better now? What questions remain for you?
Wednesday, February 16, 2011
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I can't imagine being faced with the diagnosis of a chronic condition, especially at such a young age. Normally your grandparents have medical chronic medical conditions or maybe even parents but it's more rare for children to be diagnosed with chronic conditions. Like Rachel, I have always imagined myself having children so to be faced with information telling me that I could not have children, I would be devastated. I'm glad to know that this is not totally true with PCOS but I feel like most people diagnosed with a medical condition would run to the internet to look up information. I think it's very important for medical providers to discuss the conditions thoroughly and let the patient know where to find accurate information. I think it would be very difficult to be faced with a disorder that involved weight gain and diet restrictions, especially in the most judgmental years of your life. Fortunately Rachel has a family that was willing to change eating habits with her so she didn't have to do it alone. I don't think all families would change their lifestyle to accommodate one person. Even with family support, there is still going to be an issue eating with friends. It would be difficult for me to go out and eat with friends and pick something healthy when everyone else was eating pizza. I am a very unhealthy eater so this condition would be VERY difficult for me and I would probably avoid going out to eat with friends because of the temptations. It is unfortunate that people are so judgmental with weight gain and I don't really know why this specific condition is so judged. I think people automatically assume that the person did this to themselves by overeating and being lazy but people shouldn't assume this. There are a number of medical conditions that cause weight gain and also genetics has a factor. I think society in general would just rather judge others than look in the mirror at their own issues.
ReplyDeleteI found the class discussion incredibly interesting and informative. We have referenced PCOS in a few of our therapeutics classes, but I never really understood what it was and also thought that it was a disease primarily regarding ovarian dysfunction. Being able to hear firsthand from a woman our age suffering from PCOS was also very helpful. I can't imagine how hard it would be to be diagnosed with PCOS. Middle school was an awkward time for me anyway, as I think it was for everyone. Gaining another 30-50 lbs would only add to how hard it was to adjust to who you were becoming. Personally, it would be very hard for me to maintain a PCOS diet. While completing the diabetes patient activity in therapeutics, I found it hard to stick to a diabetic diet, and this would be even more strict. Many of the foods that we talked about that were listed on the "high glycemic index" list were foods that I very much enjoy.
ReplyDeleteI was so glad we discussed this topic in class. I had heard the term thrown around a couple times before this class but never really know what it meant and what the pathophysiology was of this disease. When my sister and I were in high school, our PCP after finding out my sister did not have regular periods and struggled with very stubborn acne told my sister she wanted to do tests for polycystic ovarian syndrome. After the necessary tests it was determined that my sister did not have polycystic ovarian syndrome and her menstrual irregularity was due to her small size and how physically active she was. In a way it was good that my primary care physician was looking at more of the complete picture and all possibilities for my sister’s menstrual irregularities but like we talked about in class it can be really scary when medical professionals throw around various medical conditions and terms without fully explaining them first because it can be very concerning especially for a young person to be faced with the possibility of a disease that will have lifelong complications. I think it’s really weird that a disease so common is not covered anywhere at all in the course of our normal curriculum, especially since many of the symptoms can be things that can be glossed over as more severe aspects of normal adolescent problems.
ReplyDeleteBefore this class I would have never thought that someone on metformin we on it for any reason other than diabetes so I understand how it would be a problem with medical providers assuming any patient they saw on metformin had diabetes, but I also think that is a great example of why and medical providers we should not jump to assumptions about patients solely on their medication list. With all the advances in medication there are so many different indications for drugs both on and off label and since you are not generally there with the doctor as they are making their medication decisions you cannot just assume you know exactly what conditions a patient has.
In high school about once a month on a Friday morning my friends and I would meet at a bagel place for breakfast before school or we would meet at Bravo an Italian restaurant for a girl’s night out. Either way carbohydrates were what our big interactions focused around. I never really thought about how many of my interactions with friends revolved around food. Even know whenever I meet with friends from high school at home it always feels like the go to activity is to meet somewhere for dinner to catch up. I can only imagine how much more difficult this would be if I were diagnosed with a condition that caused me to have to greatly watch what I was eating.
I'm glad we covered PCOS - I had thought that I knew a fair bit about the disease (I knew of women taking metformin for it, I knew it could cause body hair and acne, etc), but I had always thought that insulin levels would be low and blood glucose would be high, so I'm glad that my mis-information was corrected.
ReplyDeleteMy father is a very hard to control Type I diabetic, so I have seen first-hand how hard it can be to count carbohydrates, not be able to fully partake in birthday parties, and things of that nature, and as a child my parents greatly restricted my sister's and my access to sugary drinks and things like that. I'm sure it's even harder when there is weight gain and not much information about a disease, and especially when puberty is thrown into the mix. I think it's good to remember that regardless of a condition, a patient's appearance, or why they are taking a medication, it is not our job to judge them for it - people get enough of that from others and they don't need it from health care professionals. I think talking to actual patients can help remind us of this.
I have always said that middle school is the one time in my life that I would never want to relive. I would say the majority of 6th, 7th, 8th graders are just plain brutal. I cannot imagine going through all the changes associated with PCOS (weight gain, acne, hair growth) at this age. Being a kid and teenager usually consists of being able to eat whatever you want without thinking about it. Just like the others who have commented, my friends and I always pigged out at sleepovers and parties. Having to constantly think about what you are eating is a huge burden to put on anyone much less a teenager. One of the huge points I learned in class is while PCOS is a medical disorder, it can very much affect the social and emotional life of these patients as well.
ReplyDeleteI was also surprised to learn how many women are affected by this disorder. It seems that many medical professionals are unaware what PCOS really is or how common it is. I started having menstrual irregularities a few months after first starting my period and was taken by my mom to see a gynecologist. I had no exam performed, no labs drawn, and few questions asked. I was simply put on birth control to regulate my periods and sent on my way. Looking back, I am surprised that more care was not taken in ruling out potential causes and possibly PCOS. It is so important as pharmacists and medical professionals that we do not make assumptions about our patients and their health issues.
I really found this class over PCOS insightful. I did not know anything about the disorder and like what was said during class, the name polycycstic ovary syndrome does sound like an infertility problem and not an insulin problem. Middle school, the time a girl will usually hit puberty, is the "ugly" time when everything is coming in at the wrong places (acne, weight, breasts,etc.,) I cannot fathom how a girl would feel of gaining an enormous amount of weight at that age and how her life would drastically change. It really makes you think twice about judging people on weight which sometimes is a natural response especially for a health care profession. I am really happy to have learned about the symptoms and what scares me the most is the irregular periods.
ReplyDeleteI have always had irregular periods and it made me think that several years without a period can be problematic. I started at age 12 but only once and then not until I was 14 did I have another one and after that it was so irregular. I remember I went to Mexico to study abroad for 5 months my sophomore year of college and only had my period once and it was light. No doctor even asked me questions about it. I finally asked to be on birth control because I had 2 months of nonstop pain that inhibited me from working out. I still don't know what is wrong with me or if it will resolve once I decide to get off OC but I wish doctor's had taken more time to examine me and ask me more questions. To be that young and not know if this is life threatening or just normal is horrible. I really wonder how many girls/women have PCOS and are undiagnosed. Also, does PCOS manifest itself in some way in men?
Before class, I really didn’t know much about PCOS, and I’d always associated it with fertility issues. I’d heard a bit about the glycemic index before class, but I’d never heard it associated with PCOS. Now I feel like I have a better understanding of the glycemic index and comprehend more how it is beneficial for a person with PCOS. Getting a PCOS diagnosis would be very daunting at any age, but especially in junior high or high school. With all the changes and issues girls face that we’ve already discussed, I can’t imagine having to be even more mindful about what to eat when going out with friends, medications, and all of the other issues associated with PCOS. Rachel’s story about going to the doctor and having to argue about her condition and medications with the doctor demonstrated how frustrating PCOS can be. I find it disheartening that some doctors don’t seem to know all that much about the condition. That would be hard as a patient or family member of a patient because we look to doctors for all of the answers. Hopefully by having a better understanding of the condition, we can better serve patients in the future.
ReplyDeleteTo start, I would like to say that I think they should change the name of PCOS back to its original name. Before class on Tuesday, I didn’t know much about the disease, but from the name I inferred that it was an ovarian disease which probably led to some sort of infertility. Yes, it is possible to experience infertility, and yes there are cysts that develop on the ovaries, but these don't seem like the main highlights of the disease…so why have it in the name? I found class on Tuesday very interesting and informative. After seeing the effects of the disease and its prevalence in the United States, I too wonder why we don’t include it in our curriculum? I think at least one therapeutics lecture should be dedicated to it, possibly after we learn about diabetes. If this were the case, the rest of our classmates wouldn’t be grouped with the other health care providers that automatically assumes everyone taking metformin is diabetic.
ReplyDeleteIn America, food is what brings people together. When you want to get together with friends or family, it usually revolves around food of some sort. Even our major holidays have a special meal associated with it. It would be very hard as a child to be diagnosed with PCOS and not be able to enjoy these special foods with everyone else. At an age where it is hard to fit in anyway, having a disease that separates you even more would be a very difficult thing to deal with. Luckily as we learn more about food properties and disease characteristics, there are more and more new recipes of "healthy" or "low-carb" versions of most dishes that taste pretty good. Hopefully families affected by PCOS are taking advantage of these recipes so as to make their wives/daughters feel less excluded by their disease.
(I have to separate my comment in parts because Blogspot keeps deleting my long comments for some reason...)
ReplyDeletePCOS is rarely talked about in the curriculum, but rightfully deserving of a more prominent place in our courses, considering the number of women diagnosed with the condition. I cannot imagine dealing with the sudden affliction of the disorder at an age when things like outward appearance and trying to define yourself as a person are so important. I can imagine that you have to grow up quickly and become more responsible to manage a disorder such as PCOS. Personally, it would have been difficult for me to overhaul my diet. My family loves sticky white rice and noodles. It would have been difficult to give up such staples; I find it great that Rachel has that supportive environment to help control her PCOS.
Adding that “human” element and meeting someone who actually has to deal with the condition on a daily basis is so important in building compassion as a healthcare provider. Before class, I assumed that infertility was the consequence of PCOS. One of my friends has PCOS, and although she does not talk about it much with me, she mentioned in passing how she believes she will be unable to have a family one day. I’m excited to pass on this information to her about methods to control PCOS to help her believe that having children is very possible!
_
ReplyDeleteTo be completely honest, I did not know really anything about PCOS. This class was very helpful and increased my awareness of PCOS. I am glad that we learned about this disease especially because it affects 8-10% of women, and we do not learn it in therapeutics. I was very surprised to hear that PCOS is caused by an excessive amount of insulin because I assumed, from the name, it was an issue with the ovaries. I truly enjoyed listening to Rachel and hearing her story first hand. I was able understand the disease more because it was from the patient’s point of view, which made the disease so real.
ReplyDeleteMiddle school is already difficult for anyone. For a child to gain 100 pounds during these critical years is devastating. It probably would affect friendships, family relationships, eating habits, and self image issues. Nobody should have to endure anything like that due to a disease. Kids should be supportive and helpful. PCOS changes the patient’s life completely. It changes their everyday life because their diet and medications have to be managed very closely. One of my good friends has celiac disease. When we go out to eat, we have to find a restaurant that has a separate gluten free menu. Luckily, many restaurants have these options today, but I could only imagine the limit that PCOS would have on social activities and even grocery shopping. Maybe someday soon there will be a new medication to help with all the symptoms of PCOS.
The changes an adolescent's body undergoes are intense - you shoot up a couple of inches over night, you gain weight, you lose weight, your cloths fit one minute, but not the next, you get horrible break outs, etc. (We were all there at one point!) But to experience such extreme changes due to PCOS at such a vulnerable age, and truly not know the reason behind it, must be horrible for both the child and the parents. I know my mom did so much for me when I was going through puberty. I had bad acne so she took me to dermatologist and spent ridiculous amounts of money (that we really didn't have) on products for me so that I might not be so upset. Parents want to do everything in their power to fix their children's problems, but in PCOS the problem can't be fixed. You have to deal with it every day. It was easy for my mom to comfort me by saying that my acne wouldn't last forever, but what if your child has a problem that will never go away? Not to mention this is a problem that they will have to face on a daily basis with the food and other health choices they make.
ReplyDeleteBeing suddenly diagnosed with a disease that causes such a dramatic increase in weight would be difficult for anyone to accept, but being diagnosed during middle school/high school would be the most challenging. As we all know, that is when you have the most pressure to fit in - to be beautiful and THIN.
The hardest part for me would be monitoring my food intake. I eat pretty healthy, but I do enjoy foods/beverages with a generally high glycemic index. Our culture is really focused on drinking and eating, especially during our college years. I would have an extremely difficult time going to hang out with my friends at a bar and not having a drink like everybody else. Plus, it is almost impossible to find a healthy food option in the places that most teenage and college students eat.
I knew very little about PCOS and I never heard of it until only about a year or so ago. I really enjoyed being able to listen to Rachel explain her struggles first hand with her "mystery diagnosis" and how it has affected her life. I could not imagine having skin color changes and gaining a handful of weight at such a young age when peers during that time in your life are already pretty judgmental and harsh.
ReplyDeleteEven though I have heard of PCOS about a year ago I still did not know that it was caused by an excess of insulin and I assumed it dealt more with the ovaries as the name implies. I can't imagine having to monitor food intake and carbohydrate intake so closely on a daily basis. It would be very difficult and depressing knowing that even if you follow a low glycemic index diet to a "T" you would not necessarily lose any excess weight. I really applaud Rachel for opening up and letting the class get a glimpse of what her life has been like and how she has dealt with the issues she has been presented with. It was very inspiring to see a woman having control over her health problems and enjoying life instead of letting her health problems take control of her.
I am glad that we were able to cover PCOS in class, since it is such a common disease state that even most healthcare professionals do not know much about. It seems to me that PCOS is not the easiest to treat, but can be fought with a combination of both pharmacotherapeutic options as well as lifestyle changes. As pharmacists (albeit future pharmacists), we are in a perfect place to both treat and counsel these patients on how to better manage PCOS (not too mention helping to educate other healthcare professionals as needed). I think the personal manner in which we learned about PCOS has helped me to better understand both the physiological and psychological effects PCOS can cause in patients. This will definitely help me when I encounter patients with PCOS in the future.
ReplyDeleteI do not know how I would manage a disease state like PCOS, since I am a forgetful person and it would require me to always be vigilant in my drug therapy and lifestyle management. I think one of the most important factors for these patients would be the kind of support they received from their family and friends.
I hope that the physiologic mechanisms behind why PCOS occurs will be discovered soon, so that we can move from treating the symptoms to treating the cause of PCOS. I am surprised that PCOS has not been added into the pharmacy school's curriculum since it occurs so often and requires various drugs to manage its symptoms.
As an aside, I think it is sad to hear that bystanders at a store or restaurant would have the audacity to give other people dirty looks based upon something they were planning on eating. That is the epitome of being judgmental since the bystander knows nothing about the person! It is such a hypocrisy in the American culture to have people commit this judgment when we as a culture claim, "Don't judge me." Anyway, that's the end of my tangent.
Overall, I found the class time covering PCOS to be very informative, and I am sure it will prove useful in the future.
Thank you to your daughter very much! It was very interesting to hear her personal thoughts on this chronic disease after learning more about it. It is not something I knew much about at all, but what I inferred from the name was not correct. I agree with the idea that perhaps it should be referred to as its original name to avoid the confusion.
ReplyDeleteI can't imagine going through the changes associated with PCOS in grade school or high school. They are hard enough times of life even if you are totally average. As a kid I was able to eat pretty much anything I wanted and only in recent years have I had to start paying closer attention to what I eat. Food is such a big part of culture and growing up I can't imagine if my mom had to take away toaster strudels! That made me a little sad to think of how hard it would have been to make those changes in the life of a kid.
I know this has personally changed my perspective on how quick I will be to judge someone by their weight. Admittedly and shamefully, it is my first instinct to associate someone who is overweight with being an over eater or being lazy or something. It is not my first thought to think of a condition like PCOS, but this was a really good class to make me be more sympathetic and less judgemental. I don't think I'm alone in that, but hopefully since I know more and can help to teach others about PCOS as well.
Thank you all - great comments which show insight and empathy. A question was asked if a PCOS like condition is seen in men. The answer is yes - I'll gather the appropriate information and post some for your reading.
ReplyDelete